That is not necessarily true.
The 3M understanding that thickness is no substitute for technology was the motivation behind the development and production of 3M’s ULTRA Safety & Security Window Films. Mil (.001”) for mil (.001”), 3M’s ULTRA Safety & Security Films provide greater tear resistance than standard PET films.
It was generally accepted that a film’s tear resistance increased its thickness increased. As other film manufacturers sought to produce films in excess of 10 mils (.010”), 3M understood that such thicker films present two fundamental problems:
- Loss of film elasticity
- Increased optical distortion
Loss of Film Elasticity
A bomb blast has two phases – a positive phase, where the glass is pushed away from the source charge, and a negative phase, where the glass is pulled back toward the source charge. These two phases subject glass to significant stress. A film with little elasticity provides little cushion during such shock. Consequently, thicker films provide less protection throughout the course of a bomb blast.
Increased Optical Distortion
Thick window films cause optical distortion from both sides of the window in a fashion similar to that of a thick pair of eyeglass lenses. This reduces an occupant’s ability to see outside with visual clarity and alters a building’s cosmetic appearance.
3M’s Response
Without sacrificing blast protection (according to third party testing) or building aesthetics, 3M developed a thinner security film comprised of an industry unique and patented system of interwoven composite polyester fibers.
A multi-layered manufacturing technique creates product elasticity to allow the film to “give” with the glass during an explosion. This “give” provides the glass with a cushion during the related stress and shock. That cushion better protects occupants from flying glass shards than would a non-elastic film.
The main benefit afforded by cross-weaving polyester fibers is that tear resistance is maximized. Regardless of how a window breaks, the applied film will be torn against its grain. Consequently, an 8-mil thick 3M ULTRA film is more difficult to tear than a competitor’s 11-mil thick standard film. This strong, thin film increases tenant safety without creating the associated optical distortion of thicker films.
Only the 3M Company manufactures micro-composite multi-layered security films. However, for clients (especially government clients) who must adhere to a set specification for film thickness, 3M offers single-layered films in 7, 8, and 14 mil thicknesses.